Types
of Business Entities
Deciding whether
to incorporate is a major decision.
After reviewing the advantages, disadvantages and various types
of corporations, it is often helpful to compare the alternatives to
incorporating. Deciding which business form is
best is a personal decision that should be based on your particular
situation and objectives, preferably with financial and/or legal advice.
The following business forms are alternatives to forming
a corporation, though certain forms have specific requirements that
may not be met by a general business:
The
discussion that follows will focus on the characteristics of each type
of entity, the common advantages and disadvantages of using that form,
and the tax treatment received by each entity.
Sole
Proprietorship
The sole proprietorship is the simplest and
most common form of business entity. In effect, a sole proprietorship is a business
that is conducted by a single individual owner (the “sole proprietor”).
The proprietor may hire any number of employees to assist in the
business, but remains the sole owner.
This business form avoids many formalities and fees incurred
in connection with other forms of business organizations.
Sole proprietors may conduct business under their own name by simply
doing business, for example, as “Paul Prescott.” A sole proprietor can also do business under a trade name (sometimes
called a “fictitious name”), for example as “Paul’s Printing.” If a sole proprietor operates under a trade
name or fictitious name, he is usually required to file a form (a “fictitious
name statement” or similar document) in the municipality where his business
is located.
Advantages
of a Sole Proprietorship
-
Sole
proprietorships are simple to start, and avoid the operating expenses
required for other legal entities such as corporations (additional
expenses for other forms of business may include incorporation expenses,
franchise taxes, and professional fees).
This is because the complex statutes governing corporations,
partnerships, and other business entities usually do not apply to
sole proprietorships.
-
Sole
proprietors make their own business decisions and thus avoid the conflicts
that may occur among partners of a partnership or shareholders of
a corporation.
-
The
owner of a sole proprietorship reports the profits of the business
on his individual income tax returns and pay taxes on them. For legal and tax purposes, there is no distinction
between the individual sole proprietor and the business. The issue
of “double taxation” that must be considered in a “C” corporation
does not pertain to a sole proprietorship.

Disadvantages of a Sole Proprietorship
-
Because there is no legal
distinction between the individual sole proprietor and the business,
the individual owner is personally liable for all of the debts
and other obligations of the business.
If the business is unsuccessful, the owner is personally liable
for payment of all business debts such as bank loans and unpaid bills
to vendors and service providers (accountants, attorneys, etc.).
If the owner’s assets are insufficient to satisfy the outstanding
debt, the owner may be forced to declare bankruptcy.
-
It may be more difficult to obtain outside
financing for a sole proprietorship, because a bank or other finance
source usually looks at the net worth and individual credit history
of the sole proprietor.
-
Raising additional capital to start or expand
the business is limited, as a practical matter, to “debt financing”
(e.g., loans). Because
the sole proprietorship has only one owner, the proprietor therefore
cannot sell “equity interests” (such as stock, or partnership interests)
as may be done by corporations and other forms of business.
-
A sole proprietorship is a greater financial
risk for the business owner. In
addition to being personally liable for all obligations of the business,
the sole proprietor has personal liability for the negligent
or willful acts of employees or agents. Thus, if an employee were to negligently injure a third person (like
a customer or client) in the course of the employee’s duties, a sole
proprietor may (along with the employee) be personally liable for
the damages. If a sole proprietor
does not have insurance to cover the damages, the sole proprietor’s
personal assets (car, home, stock portfolio) would be at risk to pay
the damages.
-
Legally, a sole proprietorship is totally
identified with the owner. Therefore, on the death of the owner, the business enterprise terminates,
leaving only the assets of the business (such as equipment, accounts
receivable, and real property). The
assets used in the business are not legally separate from the sole
proprietor’s other assets. Therefore
it may be difficult to sell the business as a whole after the death
of the sole proprietor – especially if there are disputes among the
heirs.

Tax Treatment of a Sole Proprietorship
Since a sole proprietorship has no existence
separate and apart from the individual owner, any income earned from
the business is considered income of the owner.
The sole proprietorship itself is not taxed separately on its
income; rather, the sole proprietor reports business income and expenses
on his own tax return and pays tax accordingly.
This means that the net income from the business is taxed
only once (in contrast to the income from a corporation, which has
the potential for double taxation).
All
income received by a sole proprietor from his business is also subject
to self-employment tax (“SE tax”) of 15.3% in addition to the income
tax that must be paid on the profits from the business. The SE tax is
the equivalent of the Medicare and Social Security taxes paid jointly
by a corporation and an employee on the employee’s income. However,
a corporation can make an “S” election so that profits that are not
paid to shareholder-employees as salary are automatically passed through
to the shareholder-employees as profit distributions, not as payroll,
thereby saving the 15.3% Medicare and Social Security taxes.
| To
see an example of what your tax savings could be, go to the "Quick
Links" on our Home page and click on the "Calculate
Your Tax Savings" button to calculate your personal
SE tax savings by being an "S" corporation. |
General
Partnership
A
general partnership is a business enterprise entered into by two or more
persons who do not form a corporation or any other type of business entity
to operate a business. If two
or more individuals start a business together with the understanding that
each will share in the profits of the enterprise, they are considered
a general partnership even if they didn’t specifically intend to start
a general partnership. For example,
if two sisters start a mail-order business over the kitchen table and
agree to share the profits, they are usually be considered a general partnership
if they don’t form some other kind of business entity such as a corporation. Both very large and very small businesses can
operate as general partnerships. It is not necessary to have a written
partnership agreement to be considered a partnership (though it is often
advisable in order to avoid unintended results that may occur from the
application of a state’s default partnership provisions.)
For federal tax purposes, there are no restrictions on who
can be a partner in a partnership. Thus,
individuals, estates, trusts, corporations, foreign persons, and tax-exempt
entities can all be partners for federal tax purposes. State law, however, may impose some limitations.
For example, state law may only recognize individuals who are licensed
physicians as partners in a partnership providing medical services.
Like a sole proprietorship, general partnerships usually are
not required to file any certificates or other organizational documents
with municipal authorities, but they usually must file a “fictitious business
name” or similar statement in the municipality where they are located.
Statutes in the state where the partnership is formed (for example,
the California Uniform Partnership Act) typically govern the rights and
duties of the partners. These rights and duties may also be governed
by a partnership agreement if the partners choose to have one prepared.

Advantages of a General Partnership
-
The
arrangement of duties is flexible.
Each state has a general partnership act, but partners may
generally establish arrangements according to their own agreement,
which will override most of a state’s default partnership provisions.
A partnership may also have several different classes of
partners, each having different economic rights in the partnership.
-
The
arrangement of benefits is flexible.
In a corporation, allocation of profit and loss is proportional
to the percentage of stock held by each shareholder. That is, a
shareholder who owns 10% of the outstanding shares in a corporation
would be entitled to receive 10% of any dividends paid by the corporation.
In a partnership, distributions of profits, losses and capital gains
need not be directly proportional to the percentage interests held
by the partners. This flexibility
permits an individual partner to receive a disproportionately higher
percentage of profits as a reward for taking special economic risks
or for services provided to the partnership. It also permits a higher
income partner to receive a disproportionately higher share of any
loss incurred by the partnership (to offset income from other sources,
thereby reducing overall personal tax liabilities).
-
Even
though partnerships do not require the legal formality of a written
agreement, one should be created to protect the partners’ interest.
Without such an agreement, the default provisions of state
partnership law may cause unfavorable or unintended results, such
as equal shares of profits and losses regardless of original capital
contributions.
- Some
limitations control how a partnership can allocate profits and losses.
The federal tax code, for example, limits the ability of
partners to deduct passive losses against most income.
A partner may not deduct tax losses that exceed his
initial investment in the partnership plus his share of its liabilities.
- A
partnership interest may be transferable
because, unlike a sole proprietorship, a partner’s interest in the partnership
is a discrete asset. A partner may transfer his partnership interest
to his heir or estate, or to another person.
Customarily, however, transfers of a partnership interest are
restricted under the terms of a partnership agreement.
- Transfer
restrictions usually give the partnership and/or the existing partners
a “right of first refusal” when a partner wants to transfer his
interest in the partnership, even if the transfer is to a member
of his immediate family.
- One
important purpose of these provisions is to prevent existing partners
from allowing other individuals to become partners without their
consent.
- Transfers
are also restricted to prevent unfavorable tax consequences that
may occur if more than a certain percentage of partnership interests
is sold within a certain period of time.
- A
partnership pays no income tax as a separate entity; profits
and losses are passed through to the partners, and are reported on each
partner’s individual tax return.
- General
partnerships are more attractive to lenders because the lender
will look to the aggregate net worth of all the partners in making a
decision to extend credit.

Disadvantages of a General Partnership
-
Each
partner in a partnership has personal liability for the obligations
of the partnership. Each partner is liable, at a minimum, for at
least his proportionate share. Under
most circumstances, however, each partner may be liable for the entire
amount of all partnership debts and other obligations. This is known as “joint and several” liability.
It means that each partner has 100% liability to satisfy partnership
obligations to a third party, but has a corresponding right to seek
reimbursement from other partners for their proportionate share of
the payment made by such partner. Therefore, if the partnership becomes
bankrupt or insolvent, one partner with greater assets may be required
to satisfy the liabilities of the other partners even if they exceed
what would ordinarily be considered that partner’s proportionate share
of those liabilities. Great care should therefore be taken in selecting
partners.
-
Under
the partnership statutes of most states, partnerships usually terminate
upon the death or withdrawal of any partner unless the partners
agree to continue the partnership.
The partners may include a continuation provision in the partnership
agreement, or, in the event of a death or withdrawal, the remaining
partners may simply agree to continue the partnership.
Usually, the agreement to continue must be made within a specified
period of time. If there is only one partner left, however,
the partnership will be dissolved unless an additional partner (or
partners) is admitted to the partnership within a specified period.
-
Unlike
a sole proprietor, general partners may not act unilaterally in
making partnership decisions. However, partnership agreements often give
designated partners the authority to make specific kinds of decisions.
-
General partnerships are limited in their
ability to obtain financing other than debt financing. Unlike sole proprietorships, partnerships may
raise capital by selling equity interests in the partnership, but
the sale of such interests on a large scale is very difficult because
of the prospect of potential personal liability and the usually limited
market for resale of the interest.
Also, publicly traded partnerships are taxed as corporations.
Tax
Treatment of a General Partnership
One
of the advantages of a general partnership is that, like a sole proprietorship,
the business is not taxed. Instead,
income, losses, and gains are passed through to the general partners
in accordance with the allocations provided in the partnership agreement
(or proportionately to the interests held by each partner, in the absence
of a formal agreement). The
partners then report the amount allocated on their own income tax returns
and pay tax accordingly.
For
example, let’s assume that Peter joins Paul as a partner in running
Paul’s Printing. Each is a 50% partner. If Paul’s Printing
has a profit of $20,000 at the end of the year, the partnership as an
entity pays no federal or state income tax. Rather, both Paul and Peter
will receive a Schedule K-1 from the partnership indicating that each
has a $10,000 share of the $20,000 profits generated from the business.
Paul and Peter will each report this $10,000 as income on their personal
tax returns and pay the taxes on this income individually. The net income
from the partnership is taxed only once.
It
is also important to understand that profits are automatically passed
through to Peter and Paul whether or not they actually distribute
the profits to themselves. Let’s assume that they have the business
retain the $20,000 in order to expand the business the following year.
For tax purposes, they will each still report $10,000 of the profits
on their personal tax returns and pay the taxes due even though no
portion of the $10,000 profit was distributed to them.
Joint Venture (JV)
A joint venture is essentially identical to
a general partnership, except that it is usually formed either for a specific,
limited purpose or for a limited period of time.
For example, technology companies often form joint ventures to
fund research and development of a particular item useful for their respective
businesses (such as a specialized computer chip) when development might
be too expensive for either company to fund alone.
In real estate, a builder may form a joint venture with a landowner
to develop property and split profits. A joint venture is often is not
intended to have the indefinite continuity of other forms of a partnership.
Limited
Partnership (LP)
A
limited partnership (LP) is a partnership in which the duties and obligations
of the partners are divided between one or more “general partners” and
one or more “limited partners.”
A
general partner is a partner with the same liability and
power as in a general partnership, who is responsible for managing the
partnership and its operations. Like the partners in a general partnership,
general partners in an LP are personally liable for all of the
partnership’s debts and other obligations
A
limited partner, in contrast, does not participate in the
partnership’s management and day-to-day operations.
In fact, the limited liability of the limited partner usually depends
on adhering to specific prohibitions against being actively involved in
the management or operation of the partnership business. Unlike the general
partner, the limited partner is usually not personally liable for
the partnership’s debts and other obligations, except to the extent of
the capital he has contributed to the partnership (or is obligated to
contribute in the future under the partnership agreement).
A
limited partner who violates the restriction on participating in management
of the LP risks losing his limited liability for partnership debts and
obligations. Limited partners are, nonetheless, typically
given certain voting rights with respect to major partnership decisions
such as:
-
The sale of all (or substantially
all) of the partnership’s assets,
-
The admission, removal, or retention of
a partner.
Usually, the formation and operation of limited
partnerships are regulated under state statutes, which define the obligations
and duties of these classes of partners and impose other obligations.
For example, limited partnership statutes usually require that
a “Certificate of Limited Partnership” (or similar form) containing
specified information be filed with the appropriate state authority
and kept current.
The death or resignation of a limited partner
does not cause the dissolution of an LP.
However, statutes typically provide that if a general
partner dies or resigns, the LP will be dissolved unless certain conditions
are met. For example, usually
there must be at least one remaining general partner, and the certificate
of limited partnership that has been filed with the state must authorize
the remaining general partner(s) to continue the business.
The LP may also be continued if all the remaining general partners
and a specified percentage of the limited partners agree in writing
to continue the business, within a certain time period.
Advantages and disadvantages for this form of partnership
are analogous to those of a general partnership.
The main advantage of a limited partnership is the limited
liability that limited partners enjoy, protecting them against personal
liability for the partnership’s debts and other obligations.
It is therefore far easier to market limited partner interests
as an investment, particularly with respect to discrete projects such
as real estate development. However,
such limited partner interests are generally considered “securities”
and will thus be subject to regulation under federal and/or state securities
laws.
With
the advantage of limited liability, however, comes the disadvantage
of not being able to actively participate in the management of the LP.
Tax
Treatment of Limited Partnerships
A
partner in an LP is generally taxed in the same way as a partner in
a general partnership. An LP
is also given the same flexibility as a general partnership to allocate
profits, losses, and gains regardless of one’s percentage of equity
interest in the partnership.
Limited
Liability Partnership (LLP)
A limited liability partnership (LLP) is a partnership
in which the liability of all of the partners is limited.
Generally, the partners in an LLP are liable only to the extent
of their original investments; they are not responsible for the errors,
negligence, malpractice, wrongful acts, or misconduct of their partners
or employees unless they themselves are directly supervising, controlling,
or involved in the action.
This
business structure is used most commonly by professionals such as public
accountants and attorneys. In
California, in fact, only licensed accountants, architects, or
attorneys may form an LLP. This
imposes a limitation on the members of an LLP to only licensed practitioners
of the business in which the LLP is engaged. Like professional corporations,
the specific professions which may or must form an LLP instead of an LLC
are regulated by the individual states and therefore vary from state to
state.
LLPs
as a business entity are of very recent origin in California. The catalyst
for their development is a prohibition contained in the California Corporations
Code precluding persons whose occupations are dependent upon licenses,
certificates or registrations issued by the state from conducting business
in the form of a limited liability company. A limited liability company
has the combined advantages of limited liability of its members (identical
to the limited liability of shareholders in a corporation) with the “pass
through” tax treatment of partnerships ensuring that profits are only
taxed once.
LLPs
are governed like general partnerships and have a similar degree of management
flexibility. However, because
the liability of each partner is limited, LLPs are generally required
to maintain certain levels of insurance.
LLPs are regulated by state statute and are usually formed
by filing required paperwork with the Secretary of State, or appropriate
state agency, either creating an LLP or converting an existing general
partnership into an LLP.
Limited
Liability Company (LLC)
A
limited liability company (LLC) is an unincorporated association of two
or more members to conduct a business for profit.
The members are co-owners of the LLC and may be individuals, partnerships,
trusts, estates, associations, corporations, or other LLCs. Members may be from foreign countries. An LLC may have an unlimited number of members; the only restriction
is that some states require an LLC to have at least two members.
An LLC is a relatively new business entity in the United
States (though it has a long-standing history in Europe), combining aspects
of both a corporation and a partnership.
Like
a corporation, the formation of an LLC shields its members from personal
liability for the debts and obligations of the company.
Like
a partnership, an LLC allows members considerable flexibility in determining
the management structure, rights of members, allocation and distribution
of profits and losses, and transferability of memberships. These provisions are contained in the LLC’s Operating Agreement
(a required document similar to a partnership agreement). The increased flexibility in management is
one advantage of an LLC over a corporation.
For example, an LLC may be managed in the following ways:
-
Solely
by its members (similar to a partnership)
-
By
its members and a management committee (serving in a function
similar to the board of directors of a corporation)
-
By its members, a management committee,
and officers (appointed by the members, by the management committee,
or both)
-
Solely by one or more managers

Additionally, an LLC may have more than one class of
equity interest (ownership) and may provide for allocations of profits,
losses, and distributions disproportionate to the percentage
of equity interest held in the LLC.
In 1988, the IRS granted “pass-through” status to LLCs.
As a result, an LLC may elect to be taxed like a partnership.
An LLC is typically formed by filing a document, generally
called “Articles of Formation” or “Certificate of Formation” (or “Articles
of Organization” in California) with the Secretary of State.
Advantages
of an LLC
-
The limited liability
of a corporation is combined with the flexible management and allocation
options of a partnership.
-
Using the LLC form of conducting business
will not be an impediment to raising capital in offerings of the company’s
securities because of the protection against liability afforded to
equity holders and the ability to provide for free transferability
of equity interests.
-
Many states now permit professionals
to operate their practices through LLCs, but in such instances a professional
may have personal liability not only for their own negligence or misconduct,
but also for the negligence or misconduct of other professionals under
their direct supervision. California,
however, does not allow persons whose occupation requires a
professional license or certificate to operate as an LLC.
-
Like a partnership, an LLC pays no income
tax as a separate entity; profits and losses are passed through
to the members.

Disadvantages of an LLC
-
A state may require an LLC
to have a limited life or specific termination date.
-
An LLC does not have stock – and thus does
not get the benefit of stock ownership and sales. “Interest certificates” or “membership certificates”
represent members’ interests in the LLC.
-
As in a partnership, it is advisable to
have a written Operating Agreement prepared (similar to a partnership
agreement) to avoid automatic application of a state’s default provisions
and possible unintended results. The legal cost of preparing a tailored
Operating Agreement may greatly exceed the cost of forming a corporation,
particularly an “S” corporation that enjoys many of the same characteristics
and advantages of an LLC.
-
Major
California disadvantage: LLCs
in California are subject to the payment of a gross receipts
fee on their gross revenues from all sources (not
taxable income, which may be a substantially lower amount after
deducting expenses). The first $250,000 of gross revenue is exempt
from the gross receipts fee. Thereafter, each increasing income
range pays a higher fixed fee. This fee is in addition to
the payment of the minimum franchise tax of $800 that must be paid
annually by LLC's in California. Also, the $800 franchise tax is
not credited against the gross receipts fee. To
see the table of current gross receipts fees in California, click
here.
Tax
Treatment of Limited Liability Companies
Unless it elects to be taxed as a corporation,
the tax treatment of an LLC is the same as that of a partnership or
sole proprietorship. That is,
the profits and losses are passed through to the members of the LLC
and there is no tax “at the entity level.”
For
more information about LLC's, go to the Limited Liability Company section
of the Learining Center.
|