Business
Entity Comparison Table
Introduction
Choosing
the right business entity allows you to reduce liability exposure, minimize
taxes, and ensure that the business can be financed and operated efficiently. Formalizing
the business structure also clarifies the ownership stakes of all participants
in the venture. But with so
many business entities available, choosing the “right” form can be a
daunting task for the entrepreneur.
When choosing a business entity, you should consider several
factors, including:
-
The
degree to which your personal assets are protected from liabilities
arising from the business;
-
How
to best pursue tax advantages for maximizing the tax benefits of
start-up losses, avoiding multiple layers of taxation, and converting
ordinary income to long-term capital gain;
-
Attractiveness
to potential investors and creditors;
-
The
ability to offer ownership interests to attract employees; and
-
The
costs and ease of forming and operating the business entity.
This, of course, is not an exhaustive list. Usually, your choice will depend both on general
considerations as well as specific characteristics of your business. For
a general comparison of how several factors differ among the basic types
of business entities, please refer to the table below.
Hints
on using the table:
Click
on any business
entity heading (“Sole Proprietorship,” etc.) at the top of any column to be taken to the page
on this website offering a more in-depth discussion of that
particular business entity.
Click on any topic
question (e.g.,“Pass-through
taxation?” ) in the first
column of any row to be taken the discussion of that topic that
appears on this page below the table.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
No
|
Only
for limited partners
|
Yes
|
Yes
|
Yes
|
|
|
Yes
|
Yes
|
No
|
Yes
|
Yes
|
|
|
No
|
No
|
Yes
|
Yes
|
No
|
|
|
Limited
|
Limited
|
Yes
|
No
|
Limited
|
|
|
No
|
No
|
Yes
|
Yes
|
No
|
|
|
Yes
|
Yes
|
No
|
No
|
Yes
|
|
|
No
|
No
|
Yes
|
Yes,
limited
|
No
|
|
|
No
|
No
|
Yes
|
Yes
|
Yes
|
|
Who
owns the business?
|
Sole
proprietor
|
Partners
|
Shareholders
|
Shareholders
|
Members
|
|
|
Yes,
only one
|
Yes-minimum
of two, no maximum
|
No
|
Yes-maximum
of 75
|
No
|
|
|
Sole
proprietor
|
General
partners
|
Board
of Directors
|
Board
of Directors
|
Members
or Manager
|
Explanatory
Comments
Limited
liability for owners?
-
Sole
Proprietorship: No. The owner has
unlimited liability for debts and obligations of his business.
-
Partnership: There are two types of partnerships: general partnerships
and limited partnerships. In general partnerships, all partners
have the right to participate in the management of the business
and have unlimited liability for the partnership debts. Limited
partnerships have one or more general partners and one or more limited
partners. Limited partners
enjoy limited liability, but cannot be involved in the active management
of the partnership without losing limited liability.
-
C
Corporation: Yes. Owners, known
as shareholders, enjoy limited liability. That is, their liability
is limited to their capital investment in the corporation, but their
personal assets are not at risk for the debts and obligations of
the business.
-
S
Corporation: Yes. Same as C corporation.
-
Limited
Liability Company: Yes. Owners, known
as members, enjoy the same limited liability as shareholders in
a corporation.

Pass-through
taxation?
-
Sole
Proprietorship: Yes. There is no legal distinction between the owner and
the business for tax or liability purposes. Therefore, all income
taxes are paid by the owner on his personal income tax return. The
sole proprietorship does not pay income tax as an entity.
-
Partnership: Yes. Partnerships are pass-through entities. Each partner
reports business profits or losses on his personal tax return in
proportion to his percentage interest in the partnership. The partnership,
as an entity, does not pay income taxes.
-
C
Corporation: No. A C corporation
is a taxable entity separate from its owners/shareholders. The C corporation files income tax returns and
pays taxes as an entity on its profits. Profits and losses do not
pass through to the shareholders. Payments made to shareholder-employees,
however, reduce the corporation’s taxable income and are reportable
by the shareholders as income on their personal tax returns.
-
S
Corporation: Yes. An S corporation
is not taxed federally at the entity level. Profits and losses pass through to S corporation
shareholders, who report such profits or losses on their individual
tax returns in an amount proportionate to their respective ownership
interests. For example, one who owns 25% of the corporation will
report and pay taxes individually on 25% of the corporation's profits.
State income or franchise tax may still be payable.
-
Limited
Liability Company: Yes. An LLC’s profits
and losses pass through the LLC to its owners/members in the same
manner as partnerships. State franchise taxes may still be payable.
In California, all LLC’s are also subject to a gross receipts fee
on their annual gross income from all sources.

Continuous
life?
-
Sole
Proprietorship: No. The owner of
a sole proprietorship has no separately existing business entity. Thus, if the owner dies, the sole proprietorship
terminates.
-
Partnership: Possibly. A partnership will dissolve upon a partner’s
withdrawal, incapacity, or death, unless there is a continuation
provision in a written partnership agreement.
-
C
Corporation: Yes. Once formed,
a corporation continues in existence until it is formally terminated
(dissolved). This is a corporation’s distinguishing characteristic
of perpetual existence.
-
S
Corporation: Yes. Same as C corporation.
-
Limited
Liability Company: Possibly. Although the law will differ from state to state,
an LLC is usually treated like a partnership in this respect.

Flexibility
to select tax year?
-
Sole
Proprietorship: No. The tax year of the business must generally be the same
as the individual, a calendar year ending December 31.
-
Partnership: No. As a pass-through entity, the tax year must generally
be a calendar year unless prior approval is obtained from the IRS
for specific business reasons.
-
C
Corporation: Yes. A C corporation
may choose any fiscal year end, that is, the last day of any month
of the year, as its accounting year end.
-
S
Corporation: No. An S corporation
must be a calendar year corporation, unless prior approval is obtained
from the IRS for specific business reasons.
-
Limited
Liability Company: No. Same as a partnership if taxed as a partnership.

Free
transferability of ownership interests?
-
Sole
Proprietorship: No. Since the sole
proprietor is the sole owner of his business, he cannot transfer
an interest in his business – unless the entire business is sold.
-
Partnership: No. A partnership
interest may be transferable (because it is a discrete asset, unlike
a sole proprietorship). Customarily,
however, transfers of the partnership interest are restricted under
the terms of a Partnership Agreement.
-
C
Corporation: Yes. Shares of stock
are freely transferable, limited only by securities laws or by restrictions
in the corporation’s bylaws. Shareholders may, however, enter into
a written agreement placing restrictions on the free transferability
of the corporation’s shares.
-
S
Corporation: Yes. Same as C corporation,
with the additional restriction that transfers are limited to persons
and entities that qualify as S corporation shareholders.
-
Limited
Liability Company: No. Interests are
transferable, but unanimous or majority consent of the nontransferring
members is usually required under state law or the LLC’s Operating
Agreement. Additionally, restrictions in an Operating Agreement
may allow the transfer of an economic interest only, that is, the
right to receive profits and distributions, but not the right to
vote or participate in the management of the business.

Simple
to form?
-
Sole
Proprietorship: Yes. Other than filing
a D.B.A., trade name or "assumed name" statement (if necessary)
and obtaining a business license (if required), an entrepreneur
may form a sole proprietorship simply by conducting business.
-
Partnership: Yes. Same as sole
proprietorship, with the recommendation that the partners should
enter into a written partnership agreement specifically addressing
major issues such as the management of the business, transferability
of interests, requirements to invest additional capital, if needed,
and events causing dissolution.
In a limited partnership, it is essential to have a written limited
partnership agreement covering the same major issues as discussed
above for general partnerships. It is also generally required to
file a certificate of limited partnership or similar document with
the Secretary of State or equivalent state governmental agency to
perfect the formation of a limited partnership.
-
C
Corporation: No. Articles of Incorporation
must be filed with the state, bylaws need to be drafted, stock needs
to be issued, a corporate bank account must be opened, tax filings
must be made, and generally a form listing the corporation’s directors
and officers needs to be filed with the state.
-
S
Corporation: No. Same as C corporation,
with the addition that a written subchapter S election form must
be filed with the IRS within approximately 75 days of incorporation. Some states require an S election filing to
be made with the state as well.
-
Limited
Liability Company: Formation is very similar to a partnership, though an initial
filing with the state is required to create an LLC. Unless there
is only one member, it is generally necessary to enter into a written
Operating Agreement covering many of the same topics as listed above
for partnerships.

Easy
to raise capital through investors?
-
Sole
Proprietorship: No. Short of selling
his entire business, an owner cannot sell shares or portions of
his sole proprietorship to investors. Raising
capital is limited to personal contributions and debt financing
(loans), requiring the owner’s personal collateral.
-
Partnership: No. In a general
partnership, there may be specific restrictions on admitting additional
partners who would invest additional capital into the partnership
for a percentage of the business. Also, it is very difficult to
find third party investors who are willing to be subjected to unlimited
liability as partners. With debt financing as the common method
of raising capital, the partners will have personal liability for
the repayment of any loans.
-
C
Corporation: Yes. Corporations may raise capital by selling shares
to investors. The shares
offered may be of various classes (with different financial provisions,
for example). Also, a C corporation
has no limitation on the number or type of its shareholders, though
permission is generally required from federal and/or state securities
regulators when the number of shareholders exceeds a specified amount,
is accompanied by advertising, or contains other factors not permitted
to receive an exemption from approval of a stock offereing. Subject to applicable securities laws, shares may be offered to the
public at large, maximizing the potential access to capital.
Additionally, a corporation may obtain loans, if
it has sufficient credit history. In any event, shareholders should
expect to be required to sign personal guarantees for certain types
of transactions entered into in the corporation’s name, such as
bank loans, office leases and major equipment leases.
-
S
Corporation: Yes, although in
a more limited capacity than a C corporation. First,
transfers of shares are restricted to persons and entities that
qualify as S corporation shareholders. Second, an S corporation
may have no more than 75 shareholders. Third, an S corporation may offer only one
class of stock (though differing voting rights are allowed).
-
Limited
Liability Company: No. Same as partnership.

Restrictions
on kind of business?
-
Sole
Proprietorship: No. A sole proprietorship may engage in any legally
permitted business.
-
Partnership: No. Same as sole proprietorship.
-
C
Corporation: Limited. The law varies, but some states have special
provisions relating to the formation of banking, insurance, and
other special businesses as corporations.
-
S
Corporation: Same as C corporation.
-
Limited
Liability Company: Yes. Same as C corporation. Additionally, some states
have limitations or restrictions on the types of businesses that
may operate as an LLC. In California, persons engaged in most occupations
that are licensed by the state are prohibited from operating a business
as an LLC. Common examples include real estate agents and brokers,
insurance agents and building contractors, as well as all professions
that are required to incorporate a professional corporations.

Restrictions
on number of owners?
-
Sole
Proprietorship: Yes. Like the name implies, this entity may have
only one owner. However,
a husband and wife team may own and operate a sole proprietorship.
-
Partnership: Yes. A general partnership must have at least two
partners. A limited partnership
must have at least one general partner and one limited partner.
-
C
Corporation: No. Most states allow
one-person corporations; some require at least two shareholder/owners. There
is no maximum number of owners of a C corporation, though federal
and state securities laws require approval before issuing shares
to more than a specified number of shareholders.
-
S
Corporation: Yes. Same as C corporation, plus an S corporation
must limit its shareholders to 75 or fewer.
-
Limited
Liability Company: Generally, no. Almost
every state now permits single member LLC's.

Who
makes managerial decisions?
-
Sole
Proprietorship: The sole proprietor
makes all decisions.
-
Partnership: In a general partnership,
the partners make all decisions, though the partnership agreement
may specify different managerial control among the partners.
In a limited partnership, only the general partner(s)
make managerial decisions (limited partners do not participate in
management).
-
C
Corporation: The board of directors
(elected sannually by the shareholders) manages the corporation.
Shareholders, unless acting as directors, typically do not
participate in active management of the corporation.
-
S
Corporation: Same as C corporation.
-
Limited
Liability Company: Typically, the members
manage the LLC. However, the members may elect or appoint one or
more managers to smanage the LLC. Thus, an LLC is referred to as
either “manager-managed” or “member-managed.” With a manager-managed
LLC in particular, it is essential to have a written operating agreement
that clearly describes the rights and limitations of the manager(s)
and the circumstances in which approval of the members is required.

|